June 3, 2026
picksbycard
Head-to-head comparison

it Student Cash Back vs 2 Visa Credit Card: Which Is Actually Worth It?

Discover needs a thin file; Petal can approve with zero credit history using cash flow underwriting.

Discover
•••• •••• •••• 1223
it Student Cash Back
Student
Discover

it Student Cash Back

Average earners get double their cash back in year one with no annual fee tacked on.

Petal
•••• •••• •••• 3404
2 Visa Credit Card
Petal 2
Petal

2 Visa Credit Card

Earning 2% cash back on select merchants isn't worth the risk of high APRs

Side-by-side specs

it Student Cash Back 2 Visa Credit Card
Annual fee $0 $0
Signup bonus Cashback Match - doubles all cash back earned in year one None
APR range 17.24–26.24% Variable 18.24–32.24% Variable
Foreign tx fee None None
Credit target limited or fair limited or fair

it Student Cash Back earn rates

rotating 5pct categories ×5
everything else ×1

2 Visa Credit Card earn rates

select merchants ×2
everything else ×1

The verdict

Choose it Student Cash Back if

You have some credit history (even thin) - Discover gives you rotating 5% categories and the cashback match, which Petal can't match.

Apply at Discover →
Choose 2 Visa Credit Card if

You have zero credit history and no Social Security Number alternative - Petal uses income data for approval when FICO can't.

Apply at Petal →

Track what both cards actually earn you, WalletHub Premium syncs all your cards and monitors your credit daily.

it Student Cash Back annual fee $0, APR 17.24–26.24% Variable, signup offer Cashback Match - doubles all cash back earned in year one, terms as of 2026-05-06. 2 Visa Credit Card annual fee $0, APR 18.24–32.24% Variable, signup offer None, terms as of 2026-05-06. Verify current terms on the issuer's site before applying. We earn a referral fee on approved applications referred via Apply links, at no cost to you.

Protect Yourself from Identity Theft with WalletHub Premium